🍽️ Products & Services

Expert recommendations based on quality, value, and visitor feedback

Item Price
Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag®
Signature award-winning pie with a uniquely crisp, sugary crust and tender apples, baked in a paper bag for perfect texture.
 $19.99 (9-inch)
Fresh Apple Cider Donuts
Classic farm-style donuts made with local apple cider; available in single, half-dozen, or dozen packs.
 $1.29 each / $6.99 half-dozen
Homemade Artisan Breads
Selection of fresh-baked breads, including sourdough, multigrain, and seasonal specialties.
 $4.99–$6.99
Wisconsin Cheeses
Curated local cheese selection, featuring cheddar, Colby, and specialty varieties from top Wisconsin dairies.
 $6.99–$12.99/lb
Farmhouse Deli Sandwiches
Made-to-order deli sandwiches with local meats, cheeses, and fresh bread; vegetarian options available.
 $7.99–$9.99
Seasonal Produce (Fall Apples, Pumpkins, Corn)
Locally grown fruits and vegetables, with U-pick options during harvest seasons.
 Varies by item/season
Local Jams, Jellies & Preserves
Homemade and regional preserves, including apple butter, cherry jam, and more.
 $4.99–$7.99
Gift Baskets & Seasonal Gift Boxes
Curated gift packages featuring Elegant Farmer specialties; custom options available for holidays and events.
 $29.99–$69.99

Inventory & Brands: The Elegant Farmer offers a robust inventory that blends farm-fresh produce, gourmet bakery goods, local cheese, deli fare, and regional specialty foods. The centerpiece is the Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag®, which has earned national accolades and draws pie-lovers from across the Midwest. Fresh apple cider donuts and artisan breads are local favorites, while the cheese counter features top Wisconsin brands like Renard’s and Carr Valley. The deli is known for hearty sandwiches made from locally sourced meats and cheeses, and the shelves are stocked with jams, preserves, and pickles from both the farm’s kitchen and regional partners.

Pricing: Prices are moderate and reflect the premium quality and local sourcing. The signature pie is competitively priced for its size and reputation, and deli sandwiches and baked goods offer strong value compared to similar farm markets in the region. Specialty gift baskets and seasonal produce provide a range of options for different budgets.

Special Services: Gift baskets and custom gift boxes are popular for holidays and corporate gifting—these can be pre-ordered or assembled in-store. During harvest seasons, U-pick apples and pumpkins are a highlight, and the market regularly hosts special events like hayrides and seasonal festivals. While there is no formal loyalty program, frequent shoppers benefit from seasonal coupons and occasional discounts, especially around holidays.

Policies & Practical Details: Return and exchange policies are straightforward for non-perishable items (usually with receipt and within 14 days), but food items are typically final sale due to safety standards. Payment is flexible—The Elegant Farmer accepts Visa, Mastercard, Discover, American Express, cash, and personal checks. Financing is not applicable, but large group or corporate orders can be arranged with advance notice. There are no in-house alteration or customization services (e.g., for bakery goods), but staff are happy to accommodate special gift basket requests.

Insider Recommendations: Research and visitor feedback consistently praise the apple pie and cider donuts as must-haves. Cheese lovers should ask staff for sample tastes and recommendations from the local selection. U-pick produce is best experienced early in the season for the freshest options. For holiday gifts, pre-ordering custom baskets is highly recommended as they often sell out. Note that restrooms are limited to outdoor portable units—plan accordingly, especially with kids or during high-traffic events.

✨ The Experience

🥧
Product Selection & Quality
The Elegant Farmer is best known for its award-winning baked goods and premium Wisconsin cheeses, but the overall selection is impressively broad. Visitors rave about the freshness of the produce, the authentic flavor of the bakery treats, and the quality of deli meats and sandwiches. Seasonal offerings—like U-pick apples and pumpkins—provide a true farm-to-table experience, especially in autumn.
🛒
Store Layout & Shopping Experience
The market combines rustic charm with efficient organization, making it easy to browse bakery goods, deli items, and specialty groceries. The store is wheelchair accessible, with wide aisles and clear signage. Outdoor seating and picnic tables offer a relaxed spot to enjoy your purchases, though indoor seating is limited. During festivals, expect a lively, bustling atmosphere both inside and out.
🙋‍♂️
Staff Knowledge & Helpfulness
Staff members are known for being friendly, approachable, and well-versed in the shop’s offerings. They’re happy to provide samples, offer pairing advice (especially for cheeses and bakery items), and help assemble custom gift baskets. During busy fall weekends, the team keeps lines moving efficiently while still offering personalized service.
💳
Checkout Process & Efficiency
Checkout is generally quick and hassle-free, with multiple registers open during peak times. The store accepts a wide range of payment methods, including cards and personal checks. Visitors appreciate the efficient flow, though lines can form during popular seasonal events—arriving early or visiting on weekdays is a smart move for faster service.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

What are the most popular items at The Elegant Farmer?
The Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag® is the signature item and a regional favorite. Other best-sellers include fresh apple cider donuts, artisan breads, local Wisconsin cheeses, and homemade jams and preserves. Seasonal produce, especially apples and pumpkins, are also highly sought after during harvest months.
Does The Elegant Farmer offer returns or exchanges?
Non-perishable items (such as gifts, packaged goods, and merchandise) can typically be returned or exchanged within 14 days with a receipt. Due to food safety regulations, perishable and bakery items are generally final sale. If you have a quality concern, staff are known for being helpful—don’t hesitate to ask for assistance.
Are there any special events or seasonal activities?
Yes! The Elegant Farmer is famous for its fall harvest festival, which includes U-pick apples and pumpkins, hayrides, and family-friendly activities. Throughout the year, there are also tastings, themed weekends, and special holiday gift box promotions. Event schedules are posted on their website and social media.

📖 About The Elegant Farmer

The Elegant Farmer has been a Mukwonago institution for decades, rooted in the tradition of farm-fresh foods and genuine hospitality. Its iconic yellow barn has become a regional landmark, drawing visitors for legendary baked goods—especially the Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag®, which has been featured by Food Network and Gourmet Magazine. The business blends the charm of a classic country market with the standards of a modern specialty grocer, offering everything from deli fare to Wisconsin cheeses and seasonal produce.

Locals and travelers alike appreciate The Elegant Farmer’s commitment to quality, local sourcing, and community engagement. Seasonal festivals, U-pick opportunities, and family-friendly events make it more than just a market—it’s a destination that celebrates the flavors and traditions of southeastern Wisconsin. Despite its popularity, the team maintains a welcoming, small-town feel, making every visit memorable. Whether you’re searching for a perfect pie, a unique gift, or a taste of Midwest hospitality, The Elegant Farmer delivers a truly authentic experience.