🍽️ Products & Services

Expert recommendations based on quality, value, and visitor feedback

Item Price
9-Year Aged Cheddar (Wisconsin)
Sharp, crumbly, and deeply flavorful—The Cheese Box’s signature cheese, sourced from top local dairies.
 $22.99/lb
Smoked Gouda Wheel
Creamy, subtly smoky, and perfect for snacking or entertaining.
 $7.99/wheel
Gourmet Deli Sandwiches
Made-to-order sandwiches featuring premium cheeses, Boar’s Head meats, and fresh bread. Local favorite: The Turkey & Swiss.
 $7.50–$10.00
Cheese & Sausage Gift Boxes
Curated gift boxes of local cheeses and summer sausages—perfect for holidays or special occasions. Shipping available.
 $25.00–$60.00
Fresh Cheese Curds
Classic Wisconsin squeaky curds, available plain or flavored. Always fresh and a hit with kids and adults alike.
 $6.99/bag
Specialty Meats (Boar’s Head, Local Brands)
Premium deli meats sliced to order, with an emphasis on quality and flavor.
 $8.99–$18.99/lb

The Cheese Box’s inventory is a curated love letter to Wisconsin’s dairy heritage, featuring everything from ultra-aged cheddars and buttery Goudas to tangy blue cheeses and fresh curds. The shop sources from respected local creameries and national favorites, with a rotating selection that often highlights seasonal and limited-edition finds. Their deli counter is a standout, offering made-to-order sandwiches piled high with premium meats (think Boar’s Head) and, of course, generous slices of their best cheeses. Visitors rave about unique picks like the 9-year aged cheddar (sharp and nutty), the smoked Gouda, and the fresh cheese curds that practically squeak with every bite.

Gift boxes are a specialty here—perfect for holidays, corporate gifts, or that “just because” treat. The staff will help customize boxes to your taste, and shipping is available across the U.S. (pro tip: order early around the holidays, as demand spikes!). While prices reflect premium quality, many guests note the value is excellent compared to touristy alternatives in town.

Return & Exchange Policy: Due to the nature of perishable foods, returns are generally not accepted, but staff are known to address any quality issues promptly and with courtesy.

Payment Methods: All major credit cards are accepted, including Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover. Cash is also welcome. No financing or payment plans are offered, which is standard for specialty food shops.

Special Services: Custom gift box assembly, cheese and meat tastings (just ask!), and staff recommendations for pairings. No loyalty club, but regulars are often greeted by name and receive “locals’ tips” on new arrivals. No in-store seating—this is a grab-and-go spot. No explicit discounts, but occasional specials may be promoted in-store or on their website/social media.

Insider tip: If you’re seeking something truly unique, ask about their limited-run cheeses or holiday specialty items. Staff are happy to slice samples and share pairing ideas that go beyond the basics—don’t be shy!

✨ The Experience

🧀
Product Selection & Quality
Research consistently highlights The Cheese Box’s selection as one of the best in the region: from rare aged cheddars to classic curds and specialty meats, there’s something for both cheese aficionados and casual snackers. Quality is uncompromising—every product is carefully sourced, and staff will point you toward their freshest arrivals and hidden gems.
🏪
Store Layout & Shopping Flow
The shop’s cozy, old-school layout invites browsing: cheese cases line the walls, with a central deli counter and shelves of local treats and accompaniments. While space is limited, it’s well-organized and rarely feels crowded (except for peak weekends or holidays). The absence of indoor seating means most guests shop for takeout or gifts, making visits efficient and purposeful.
🤝
Staff Knowledge & Helpfulness
Visitors consistently praise the staff’s passion and expertise—expect friendly recommendations, generous samples, and thoughtful answers to any cheese-related question. Whether you’re assembling a gift box or just looking for a new snack, the team makes everyone feel welcome and informed, regardless of your cheese IQ.
💳
Checkout Process & Efficiency
Checkout is prompt and hassle-free, with modern POS systems and multiple payment options. Waits are minimal even during busy times, and staff do their best to keep things moving while maintaining a personal touch. Expect a smooth, old-school-but-efficient retail experience—no long lines, no upselling, just genuine service.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sample cheeses before buying?
Absolutely—sampling is encouraged! Staff are happy to offer tastes of most cheeses before you commit, and they’ll guide you to their current favorites or something new if you’re unsure.
Is there indoor seating or a café area?
No, The Cheese Box is a retail shop and deli with a focus on takeout. There’s no indoor seating, so plan to enjoy your sandwich or cheese haul at a local park, the lakefront, or back at your lodging.
Do you ship gift boxes or cheese out of state?
Yes! The Cheese Box offers nationwide shipping on their curated gift boxes and select cheese/meat products. Early ordering is smart, especially during holidays, as demand is high and some specialty items may sell out.

📖 About The Cheese Box

The Cheese Box has been a beloved Lake Geneva institution since the late 1930s, serving up Wisconsin’s finest cheeses and deli fare from its iconic South Wells Street location. Over the decades, it’s become far more than a shop—it’s a hub for locals and a must-visit for out-of-towners seeking authentic flavors and a slice of regional heritage. The shop’s commitment to quality, paired with genuinely friendly service, has made it a household name across generations. Whether you’re hunting for the perfect picnic spread, a memorable gift, or just a taste of what makes Wisconsin famous, The Cheese Box delivers with old-school charm and modern expertise. Its enduring popularity is a testament not only to the quality of its products but also to its deep roots in the Lake Geneva community and the broader Wisconsin dairy tradition.