El Mariachi in Lake Mills, WI

What Sets This Restaurant Apart

El Mariachi isn’t just about tacos and burritos (though they do those well). What makes it stand out is the sheer variety on the menu and the way the kitchen leans into bold, familiar flavors—think sizzling fajitas, gooey cheese, and hearty, saucy specials. The El Super Molcajete Mariachi Special is a local legend, loaded with grilled meats, veggies, and enough fixings to feed two. Specials like Mario’s Volcanito bring a little flair to the table, and on holidays, the whole place gets decked out for themed events. If you’re after a classic, the Chicken Enchiladas ($12.50) hit the spot without breaking the bank, and the Fajita Taco Salad ($8.50) is perfect for a lighter lunch. And let’s not forget the margaritas—often mentioned in reviews, they’re the go-to for a reason.

The Offering

• Signature items/services: El Super Molcajete Mariachi Special (a sizzling platter loaded with steak, chicken, shrimp, peppers, and cheese), Mario’s Volcanito Special A (for the adventurous), Chicken Enchiladas ($12.50), and Fajita Taco Salad ($8.50). Margaritas are a must-try, especially during happy hour or Cinco de Mayo.
• Quality highlights: Most dishes come out piping hot with bold flavors and generous portions. The kitchen isn’t afraid to go big on cheese and sauce, and the chips and salsa are a staple starter. Reviewers love the “mouth-watering tasteful” bites, though some have noted occasional inconsistencies in steak dishes.
• Range & variety: The menu covers all the bases—tacos, burritos, enchiladas, fajitas, salads, and combination plates. There’s a solid vegetarian section, kid-friendly options, and enough appetizers to keep a table happy while waiting for mains.
• Seasonal/special offerings: Look for special menus during Cinco de Mayo, Mother’s Day, and other holidays. These often feature limited-time dishes, drink specials, and festive décor to match the mood.

The Experience

The lively, family-friendly atmosphere means you’ll hear laughter, birthday songs, and see tables of all ages digging in together. The walls are bright, the décor is colorful, and there’s usually upbeat music playing. It’s the kind of place where you can bring a group, celebrate, or just unwind after work. On weekends, it can get busy—expect a little wait, but the vibe is always welcoming and upbeat.

Service reality: Most of the time, the staff is friendly and attentive, but during peak hours, things can get stretched—so patience is sometimes required. Drinks tend to arrive quickly, but food can take longer if the place is packed. If you have a specific concern, don’t hesitate to ask; the team is usually accommodating.

Detailed Experience Breakdown

• Arrival process: Walk-ins are the norm, and you’ll be greeted up front. If there’s a wait, you’ll usually get an honest estimate. No fancy dress code—just come as you are.
• Space & layout: The dining room is open and easy to navigate, with a mix of booths and tables. There’s enough room for strollers or wheelchairs, and the bar area is a popular hangout for singles or smaller groups.
• Interaction style: Servers are upbeat and happy to offer recommendations, but things can feel rushed if it’s busy. Regulars will tell you to flag down your server if you need something—don’t be shy.