Madison WI Ice Cream Shop

star star star star star_half

4.1

Good News Café & Ice Cream in Madison, WI

Savor inventive, house-made ice cream and Mexican hot chocolate in a vibrant café with friendly vibes, vegan options, and ever-changing, quirky flavors!

attach_moneyattach_money

View Details

Savor inventive, house-made ice cream and Mexican hot chocolate in a vibrant café with friendly vibes, vegan options, and ever-changing, quirky flavors!
Local area information

If you’re looking for a spot in downtown Madison that feels both neighborly and a little bit special, Good News Café & Ice Cream on King Street is one of those places that manages to blend old-school café charm with a modern, local twist. It’s not just about grabbing a scoop—though, trust me, the ice cream here is a genuine highlight—but about enjoying a cozy, welcoming space that fits just about any mood, whether you’re fueling up for the day with breakfast, catching up over lunch, or treating yourself to something sweet after a Capitol stroll.

The big draw? Their commitment to inventive, in-house made ice cream (think Fig & Honey or Blueberry Honey Lavender) and a café menu that’s just as thoughtfully crafted. It’s a true reflection of Madison’s love for artisanal, local flavors—and it’s a spot where families, students, and downtown professionals all genuinely cross paths.

Location & Contact

Address: 117 King St, Madison, WI 53703, USA

Phone: (608) 298-7160

Website: Official site

Parking: Street parking is available right on King St, but it can fill up fast—especially on weekends or when the Capitol is hosting events. There are a couple of reliable city parking garages within a block or two (like the Capitol Square North Garage or the Government East Garage), which are your best bet if you’re coming during peak times.

Accessibility: The café is wheelchair accessible, with step-free entry and accessible restrooms on-site. If you have specific needs, a quick call ahead is always welcome—the staff are known for being accommodating.

What's the Deal

Best for

Families, students, professionals, and anyone who appreciates creative ice cream or a laid-back breakfast/lunch spot downtown

Time needed

30–60 minutes (quicker for grab-and-go ice cream, longer for a sit-down meal)

Budget range

Breakfast: $5–$12 • Sandwiches: $5–$9 • Soups: $5–$8 • Ice cream: Typically $4–$6/scoop

Worth knowing

Indoor seating is limited, but you can often snag a spot in the adjacent Madison’s restaurant space—just ask! They also offer dairy-free ice cream options and online ordering for easy pickup.

What's the Food Scene Like

What Sets This Restaurant Apart

Good News Café & Ice Cream stands out for its genuine, small-batch approach to everything on the menu. The ice cream is made in-house, with flavors that go way beyond your standard chocolate and vanilla—think seasonal options like Fig & Honey or Blueberry Honey Lavender, and a real emphasis on local sourcing. And while the ice cream is the headliner, the café’s breakfast and lunch menu has quietly become a neighborhood favorite, especially since their 2024 menu expansion. It’s the kind of spot where you can pop in for a morning coffee and breakfast sandwich, come back later for a soup and sandwich lunch, and still have room for a scoop (or two) of something sweet.

The Offering

Signature items/services:
- In-house made ice cream: Creative flavors like Fig & Honey and Blueberry Honey Lavender are big hits. There are always rotating options, and the staff are happy to let you sample before you decide.
- Breakfast menu: Ranges from classic egg sandwiches to more inventive options, all priced between $5 and $12. The portions are generous, and everything is made to order.
- Lunch offerings: Sandwiches ($5–$9) and soups ($5 and $8) that lean into comfort food territory—think fresh, simple, and satisfying. There are vegetarian and vegan-friendly choices as well.
- Dairy-free ice cream: For those with dietary restrictions, there are always dairy-free options on hand, and the staff are attentive to allergies and preferences.
Quality highlights: All ice cream is made in-house using local Wisconsin dairy (unless it’s a dairy-free batch). The café’s commitment to unique, high-quality flavors and friendly, knowledgeable staff makes the experience feel personal and genuine.
Range & variety: There’s something for everyone—kids gravitate to the more classic or fun flavors, while adults often go for the more adventurous or seasonal picks. Breakfast and lunch options cater to omnivores, vegetarians, and those looking for lighter fare.
Seasonal/special offerings: Flavors rotate regularly, with special releases in the summer and around the holidays. Keep an eye on their social media for announcements about limited-edition flavors and events.

The Experience

The cozy, low-key atmosphere means you never feel rushed—this is a place that invites you to relax, whether you’re solo with a laptop, with friends, or wrangling a couple of kids after a Capitol visit. The music is soft and the vibe is friendly, so it’s easy to settle in for a conversation or just enjoy a quiet moment. You’ll see a real mix of customers: families grabbing afternoon treats, downtown workers on a lunch break, and students tucked in with coffee and laptops.

Service reality: The staff are known for being genuinely friendly and knowledgeable about the menu—ask about flavors or dietary needs and you’ll get thoughtful answers. Service can be a bit slower during peak times (especially weekend evenings or summer afternoons), but the team works hard to keep things moving and keep customers happy.

Detailed Experience Breakdown

Arrival process: Walk in and you’ll find the ice cream case front and center, with the café counter right beside it. Place your order at the counter; there’s no table service, but staff will help you get settled if you need anything.
Space & layout: The main space is intimate, with just two tables and a counter facing the window. If it’s full, you can ask to use a table in the adjacent Madison’s restaurant, which expands your options. There’s also a bit of outdoor seating in nicer weather.
Interaction style: Expect a laid-back, welcoming approach. Staff are happy to let you sample ice cream, explain menu items, and accommodate special requests. It’s a first-come, first-served setup—no reservations, but the flow is usually pretty smooth outside of peak times.

Important Considerations

Strengths & Considerations

Key Strengths: Standout, creative ice cream flavors made in-house; genuinely friendly and knowledgeable staff; an inviting, family-friendly atmosphere; great location close to the Capitol; and a menu that now covers breakfast, lunch, and treats.

Things to Keep in Mind

Indoor seating is limited, especially during busy times—be ready to grab a spot next door or opt for takeout if it’s packed.
Service can be slower during peak hours, particularly on weekends and summer afternoons when foot traffic spikes.
No reservations accepted, so timing your visit (or being flexible) is your best bet for a relaxed experience.

This is a spot that delivers on quality and charm, but it’s not ideal if you’re looking for a large-group hangout or need guaranteed seating during peak hours. It’s best enjoyed when you can go with the flow and take your time.

FYI (For Your Information)

Timing & Logistics

Best times: Early afternoons on weekdays are your sweet spot—less crowded and more relaxed. • Peak periods: Evenings (especially Thursday–Saturday) and sunny weekend afternoons tend to get busy, with more families and post-dinner crowds. • Seasonal notes: Summer brings a big bump in foot traffic thanks to Madison’s downtown events and Capitol visitors. If you want to avoid a wait, try coming in the morning or early afternoon.

What You Need to Know

Booking/Access: It’s always walk-in only—no reservations, but you can order online for quick pickup if you want to skip the line.
Payment & Costs: Credit cards are accepted, and prices are moderate for downtown: breakfast ($5–$12), sandwiches ($5–$9), soups ($5–$8), ice cream ($4–$6). No hidden fees or surcharges.
Facilities & Amenities: Wheelchair accessible, with restrooms on-site. Street parking is hit-or-miss, but nearby public garages are reliable. Seating is limited, so don’t bank on a big group table unless you check next door at Madison’s.
Preparation: Come as you are—casual attire fits right in. If you’re planning to work or linger, bring headphones and maybe a book; space is cozy, so be mindful of others during busy times.

Insider Tips

Local knowledge: If the main café is full, just ask about grabbing a seat in Madison’s next door—they’re happy to accommodate. Also, check the café’s Instagram or Facebook for fresh flavor drops and seasonal specials; locals know to pop in when a new batch hits the case.

Managing Expectations

What works well: The rotating ice cream flavors and breakfast sandwiches are always crowd-pleasers. Service shines when it’s not slammed, and the vibe is genuinely welcoming for families and solo diners alike.
Potential limitations: Space is tight, and things slow down during peak periods. It’s not the spot for a lingering, hours-long brunch if it’s packed.
How to optimize: Visit during off-peak hours, order ahead online if you’re in a hurry, and don’t be shy about sampling before you settle on a flavor. If the weather’s nice, take your treat for a walk around the Capitol Square.

Timing Considerations

Summer is prime time here—expect lines out the door on weekends and during downtown events, especially when the weather’s nice. That’s when their unique ice cream flavors really shine, but it’s also when patience is key. Winter brings a quieter, cozier vibe, and you might have the place practically to yourself on a snowy weekday afternoon. Holiday seasons often mean special flavors and festive décor, so keep an eye out for those limited-time treats.

The Local Food Culture

Good News Café & Ice Cream fits right into Madison’s food culture, where local sourcing, creativity, and a sense of community matter. The café’s commitment to in-house made, small-batch ice cream and a rotating menu of comfort food classics speaks to the city’s love for artisanal flavors and supporting local businesses. It’s a place that locals use in a bunch of different ways: families make it a weekend tradition, students swing by for a study break treat, and downtown workers know it as a reliable spot for a quick, quality lunch or a pick-me-up after a long day.

Over time, Good News has become more than just another café—it’s one of those rare spots that feels like a community anchor, especially for folks who live or work near the Capitol. Whether you’re a regular or just passing through, there’s a genuine sense of welcome, and the rotating ice cream flavors mean there’s always something new to try. In a city that values both tradition and innovation, this café manages to offer a little bit of both, all with a side of good vibes.

Final Assessment

Overall Recommendation

Bottom Line: Good News Café & Ice Cream is a downtown Madison gem for anyone who loves creative, high-quality ice cream and a welcoming, local café vibe. It’s not a spot for big groups or a long, lingering meal during peak hours, but it’s perfect for a relaxed treat or a casual bite, especially if you appreciate inventive flavors and a friendly team. With accessible pricing, a central location, and a menu that’s as thoughtful as it is delicious, it’s well worth a visit—just plan ahead if you want to avoid the crowds.

Best For

Families looking for a kid-friendly treat or outing near the Capitol
Students and professionals wanting a cozy spot for a quick breakfast, lunch, or work session
Anyone who appreciates small-batch, creative ice cream flavors and a welcoming, local atmosphere

In a city that takes its food seriously, Good News Café & Ice Cream stands out for its inventive flavors, warm service, and genuine neighborhood feel. It’s a place you’ll want to revisit—whether for your morning coffee, a mid-day sandwich, or a scoop of something you won’t find anywhere else. Just remember: timing is everything, so aim for off-peak hours if you want the full, relaxed experience.