🍽️ What to Order

Expert recommendations based on quality, value, and visitor feedback

Item Price
Margherita Pizza
Classic Neapolitan pizza with San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and extra virgin olive oil, fired in a wood oven.
 $17.00
Diavola Pizza
Spicy soppressata, mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, Calabrian chili oil—a visitor favorite for those who crave a kick.
 $19.00
Prosciutto e Arugula Pizza
Prosciutto di Parma, arugula, shaved Parmesan, and extra virgin olive oil atop a base of mozzarella and tomato.
 $19.00
Burrata Caprese
Creamy burrata cheese, heirloom tomatoes, fresh basil, olive oil, and balsamic glaze—perfect as a sharable starter.
 $13.00
Nutella Pizza
Wood-fired dough topped with Nutella and powdered sugar—a crowd-pleasing dessert for all ages.
 $10.00
Gluten-Free Pizza Crust
Available for any pizza—made in-house and suitable for gluten-sensitive diners (note: not celiac certified).
 +$3.00

Menu Highlights & Signature Dishes: Oakfire’s claim to fame is its authentic Neapolitan pizza—thin, chewy crusts with signature char, created in a blazing wood-fired oven imported from Italy. The Margherita is a textbook classic, but the Diavola is the locals’ pick for its spicy, savory kick. The Prosciutto e Arugula pizza offers a balanced, fresh bite, while seasonal specials (like the Funghi with wild mushrooms) keep regulars coming back. Don’t skip the Burrata Caprese starter or the indulgent Nutella Pizza for dessert—both consistently earn rave reviews across platforms.

Dietary Options & Allergen Info: Oakfire is notably accommodating for gluten-sensitive guests, offering a house-made gluten-free crust for any pizza (add $3). Vegan cheese is not standard, but staff are knowledgeable about menu ingredients and can advise on dairy-free or vegetarian choices. Most appetizers and salads can be customized for dietary needs. Due to the open kitchen and wood-fired oven, cross-contamination is possible—those with severe allergies should consult staff directly for guidance. Nutrition details are not posted, but pizzas are made with fresh, minimally processed ingredients.

Practical Details: Takeout is available and reliable; delivery service is not offered at this time. Wait times are generally short—even at peak hours, thanks to efficient table turnover. No formal reservations system is in place, but calling ahead is encouraged for larger groups. Payment is easy: major credit cards are accepted. Standard US tipping customs apply (15-20% for table service). Dress code is casual and family-friendly, making Oakfire accessible for any occasion.

✨ The Experience

🌅
Lakeside Ambiance
Oakfire’s prime location on Wrigley Drive delivers stunning views of Geneva Lake from both indoor and outdoor seating. The interior is modern yet cozy, with natural wood accents and plenty of natural light during the day. In warm months, the elevated patio is the go-to spot for sunset pizza sessions and people-watching.
🤝
Friendly, Efficient Service
Research shows Oakfire’s staff are attentive and upbeat, keeping things moving even during busy hours. Orders are typically delivered promptly, with staff happy to explain menu details or suggest wine and beer pairings. The vibe is professional without being stuffy—great for families, couples, and groups alike.
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦
Lively, Inclusive Crowd
Expect a diverse mix: families with kids, couples on date night, friend groups, and tourists drawn by the location. The noise level is moderately lively—enough buzz for energy, but still easy to hold a conversation. Highchairs and kid-friendly options make this a solid pick for all ages.
🪑
Flexible Seating & Layout
Oakfire offers a mix of indoor tables, bar seating, and multi-level outdoor patios. Accessibility is a priority—there’s wheelchair access, and tables can accommodate strollers and larger groups. For a quieter meal, aim for off-peak hours or request indoor seating away from the main entrance.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Does Oakfire take reservations?
Oakfire does not offer online reservations, but you can call ahead for larger parties. Walk-ins are welcome and typically seated quickly, even during peak times, thanks to efficient table turnover.
Are there gluten-free or vegetarian options?
Yes—Oakfire offers a house-made gluten-free crust for any pizza, and many pizzas and salads are vegetarian by default or can be customized. Vegan cheese is not standard, so dietary-specific requests should be communicated to staff.
Is Oakfire family-friendly?
Absolutely. Oakfire is a favorite among families, with highchairs available, a casual dress code, and a menu that appeals to both kids and adults. The lively but not overwhelming atmosphere makes it ideal for all ages.

📖 About Oakfire

Oakfire opened its doors in downtown Lake Geneva with a mission to bring true Neapolitan pizza to Wisconsin’s lake country. The restaurant quickly gained a reputation for its devotion to craft—using an imported wood-fired oven, authentic Italian flour, and locally sourced produce whenever possible. Its lakefront setting gives Oakfire an edge, attracting both loyal locals and waves of summertime visitors. The multi-level space—with panoramic indoor dining and a sought-after outdoor patio—has made Oakfire a cornerstone of Lake Geneva’s vibrant food scene. Beyond the pizza, Oakfire’s friendly service and inclusive atmosphere have cemented its status as a go-to gathering spot for families, friends, and food lovers alike.