🍽️ What to Order

Expert recommendations based on quality, value, and visitor feedback

Item Price
Garbage Pizza (12")
Signature loaded pizza with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and black olives—locally famous and a crowd favorite.
 $13.95
Pub Nachos
House-fried tortilla chips piled high with cheese, tomatoes, onions, jalapeños, and your choice of beef or chicken. Great for sharing.
 $10.95
Broasted Chicken Dinner
Crispy, juicy broasted chicken served with coleslaw and your choice of side—classic Midwest comfort food done right.
 $13.95
Italian Beef Sandwich
Thinly sliced Italian beef, slow-cooked and served on a fresh roll with au jus. Add mozzarella or giardiniera for an extra kick.
 $10.50
Gluten-Free Pizza (10")
A full lineup of classic and specialty pizzas available on a gluten-free crust—ideal for those with dietary restrictions.
 $12.95+
Friday Fish Fry
Traditional Wisconsin fish fry available Fridays, featuring battered or broiled cod with fries, coleslaw, and rye bread.
 $14.95
Build-Your-Own Pub Pizza
Start with the house dough and sauce, then add your favorite toppings—perfect for picky eaters and large groups.
 $9.95+

Menu Highlights: Next Door Pub’s pizza is its undisputed claim to fame—made from scratch daily, with a sweet, chewy crust and a variety of creative topping combinations. The Garbage Pizza is a must for first-timers, frequently praised for its generous toppings and robust flavors. Broasted chicken is another local favorite, crispy on the outside and juicy inside, and the Friday Fish Fry draws both regulars and out-of-towners for a true Wisconsin tradition. Starters like Pub Nachos and cheese curds are ideal for sharing, while sandwiches and hearty pasta dishes round out the menu for non-pizza fans.

Prices & Value: Most menu items fall in the $10–$15 range, which is a standout value given the portion sizes and quality. Pizzas (available in multiple sizes) are particularly affordable for families and groups. Lunch specials and combo deals provide extra savings, especially midweek.

Dietary Options & Allergen Info: Gluten-free pizza crusts are available, and many menu items can be customized to accommodate allergies—just inform your server. While vegetarian options are somewhat limited beyond cheese pizza and salads, staff are knowledgeable and willing to suggest modifications. Nut-based ingredients are rare, but cross-contamination is possible in a busy kitchen—those with severe allergies should exercise standard caution.

Takeout & Delivery: Both takeout and local delivery are offered, with specific delivery windows (lunch and dinner hours only). Online ordering is available via their website for maximum convenience. During peak times, expect longer waits for delivery and takeout, especially weekends and summer evenings.

Reservations & Wait Times: Next Door Pub operates on a first-come, first-served basis—no reservations accepted. Wait times can exceed 30–45 minutes during dinner rushes and tourist season, so visiting during off-peak hours (early lunch, late afternoon, or after 7:30 PM) is advised for a smoother experience.

Payment & Tipping: Major credit cards are accepted. Tipping follows standard U.S. customs (15–20% for table service). Note that split checks for large groups may take extra time during busy periods.

✨ The Experience

🍕
Dining Atmosphere & Ambiance
The vibe is classic Wisconsin pub—warm, casual, and bustling. Expect wood-paneled walls, vintage beer signs, and plenty of laughter. The energy ramps up during dinner and weekends, creating a lively but friendly backdrop perfect for groups and families. If you’re after a quieter meal, aim for early lunch or a late afternoon visit.
🤝
Service Style & Speed
Service is attentive and genuinely friendly, with staff that know the menu and keep things moving despite the crowds. Food arrives hot and fresh, but during peak times (especially Friday and Saturday nights), expect a wait both to be seated and for your order—servers do their best, but the kitchen is often slammed.
👪
Crowd Type & Noise Level
You’ll find a broad mix: local families, Lake Geneva tourists, sports fans, and after-work groups. The noise level is moderate to high—think energetic conversation, kids laughing, and the occasional cheer from the bar. Not ideal for intimate dates, but great for celebrations or casual get-togethers.
🪑
Seating Options & Layout
Seating includes roomy booths, high-top tables, and a lively bar area. There’s also outdoor seating in warmer months. The layout accommodates both small parties and large groups, but space fills up quickly—especially on weekends. Accessibility is good, with step-free entry and accessible restrooms.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Does Next Door Pub & Pizzeria accept reservations?
No, all seating is first-come, first-served. During peak dining times—especially weekends and holidays—expect a wait. Arrive early or during off-peak hours for the shortest wait times.
Are there gluten-free or vegetarian menu options?
Yes, gluten-free pizza crusts are available, and salads or cheese pizzas suit vegetarian diners. While vegan options are limited, staff can suggest modifications—just ask when ordering.
Is takeout or delivery available, and how does it work?
Takeout and local delivery are both offered. Delivery operates during specific lunch and dinner hours, with online and phone ordering available. During busy periods, order early to avoid long waits.

📖 About Next Door Pub & Pizzeria

Founded in 1973, Next Door Pub & Pizzeria has become a cornerstone of Lake Geneva’s dining scene. Known for its from-scratch pizzas and classic pub fare, it’s a beloved gathering spot for locals and a rite of passage for visitors. The pub’s welcoming, unpretentious vibe and commitment to quality have earned it a loyal following across generations. In addition to its famous pizzas, the menu spans broasted chicken, hearty sandwiches, and a famous Friday Fish Fry—showcasing the best of Midwest comfort food. Community involvement and consistency have cemented its place as a go-to for celebrations, family dinners, and casual nights out. If you want to experience Lake Geneva like a local, Next Door Pub delivers every time.