🍽️ What to Order

Expert recommendations based on quality, value, and visitor feedback

Item Price
Flat Iron Burger
Signature half-pound Angus beef burger, cheddar, house sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, served on a brioche bun.
 $13.50
Wisconsin Cheese Curds
Locally sourced cheese curds, beer-battered and fried, served with house ranch.
 $10.00
The Hangover Burger
Angus beef, fried egg, bacon, cheddar, hash browns, sriracha mayo—breakfast and burger in one.
 $15.00
Beyond Burger (Vegan)
Plant-based patty, vegan cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, vegan bun. Gluten-free bun available.
 $14.50
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Crispy fried chicken breast tossed in buffalo sauce, blue cheese crumbles, lettuce, tomato.
 $13.00
Beer Flight (4 pours)
Sample four rotating Wisconsin craft beers from the extensive tap list.
 $12.00
Kids' Mini Sliders
Two beef sliders, American cheese, served with fries. Part of the family-friendly kids’ menu.
 $8.00

Menu Highlights & Signature Dishes: Flat Iron Tap’s menu is built around craft burgers, each made from fresh Angus beef, locally baked buns, and Wisconsin cheeses. The Flat Iron Burger is the crowd favorite—simple, juicy, and perfectly seasoned. Adventurous eaters rave about The Hangover Burger, a decadent mountain of breakfast flavors stacked on a burger. If you’re after a local snack, don’t skip the Wisconsin Cheese Curds: these are cheese curds done right, with a light, crispy beer batter and creamy ranch dip.

Vegetarian and vegan diners are covered with the Beyond Burger, a plant-based option that doesn’t skimp on flavor or texture. Gluten-free buns are available upon request, and the staff is attentive to allergy concerns—just let them know when ordering. For lighter fare, salads with grilled chicken or portobello mushroom are available; kids’ meals are thoughtfully portioned and crowd-pleasers in their own right.

Beverages: The tap list is a highlight in itself, rotating through 20+ Wisconsin and Midwest craft beers. Beer flights are popular for those looking to sample the region’s best. Non-beer drinkers will find a decent selection of ciders, soft drinks, and a small but curated wine list.

Prices & Value: Most burgers range from $13 to $16, with generous portions and quality ingredients that justify the moderate price point. Appetizers, sandwiches, and kids’ dishes keep things accessible for families and groups. Happy hour specials and occasional limited-time burgers provide extra value—ask your server about current deals or seasonal creations.

  • Dietary Accommodations: Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options available. Staff is knowledgeable about menu ingredients—mention allergies when ordering.
  • Allergen & Nutrition Info: Gluten-free buns and dairy-free cheese offered. Common allergens (gluten, dairy, nuts) are present in the kitchen; cross-contamination is possible, so speak up if you have severe allergies.
  • Takeout & Delivery: Takeout is available and quick; no in-house delivery, but third-party delivery may be available in the area.
  • Reservations & Wait Times: No reservations accepted; expect waits during peak hours (especially weekends and summer evenings). Early dinners and weekday visits mean faster seating.
  • Payment & Tipping: Major credit/debit cards accepted. Tipping follows standard U.S. restaurant customs (15–20% for good service).

Insider Tip: Locals love coming for a late lunch or early dinner to beat the crowds. If you’re a beer enthusiast, ask your server for recommendations based on your taste—they know their tap list inside and out.

✨ The Experience

🍔
Dining Atmosphere & Ambiance
Flat Iron Tap delivers a lively, upbeat vibe with exposed brick, warm lighting, and a buzz of conversation that gives it real local energy. The space strikes a balance between casual comfort and modern pub style—a spot where you can show up in jeans or dress up a little for a night out. The ambiance is especially inviting for groups and families, but equally suitable for a casual date or solo burger run.
🍻
Service Style & Speed
Service is friendly, knowledgeable, and efficient, with servers who know their menu and can offer pairing suggestions from the tap list. During peak dinner hours and weekends, expect a bit of a wait for both seating and food—staff does their best, but the kitchen can get slammed. On off-peak days, the experience is notably prompt and attentive.
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦
Crowd Type & Noise Level
The crowd is a blend of locals, out-of-towners, and families—Flat Iron Tap is a community favorite. Noise levels are moderate to high, especially on weekends or when a big game is on TV, so expect some lively background chatter. Those seeking a quieter meal should target weekday afternoons or early dinners.
🪑
Seating Options & Layout
Seating includes comfortable booths, high-top tables, and a handful of outdoor spots when weather allows. The layout is open and accessible, with clear pathways for wheelchairs and strollers. Tables accommodate groups or couples, and there’s a small bar area for solo diners or those focused on the tap list.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a reservation to dine at Flat Iron Tap?
No, Flat Iron Tap does not accept reservations. All seating is first-come, first-served. During busy weekends or summer evenings, expect a wait—arriving early or visiting on weekdays can help you get seated faster.
Are there options for vegetarians, vegans, or gluten-free diets?
Yes. The menu includes a plant-based Beyond Burger, salads, and gluten-free buns. Vegan cheese is also available. Let your server know about any allergies or dietary restrictions—they’re trained to help with substitutions and ingredient questions.
Is Flat Iron Tap family-friendly?
Absolutely. The restaurant offers a dedicated kids’ menu, high chairs, and is welcoming to families. The lively, casual environment makes it a great choice for groups with children.

📖 About Flat Iron Tap

Flat Iron Tap has become a cornerstone of Lake Geneva’s food scene since opening its doors, known for elevating the humble burger into a true gourmet experience. The ownership’s commitment to sourcing local meats, cheeses, and produce supports area farmers and keeps the menu fresh and seasonal. Flat Iron Tap’s ever-changing tap list is a celebration of Wisconsin’s craft beer culture, and their friendly, knowledgeable staff make even first-timers feel like regulars. The restaurant’s central location in downtown Lake Geneva makes it a hub for locals and a must-stop for visitors exploring the area. Flat Iron Tap’s blend of community spirit, quality ingredients, and inventive comfort food has secured its place as a beloved gathering spot that reflects the best of Lake Geneva hospitality.