🍽️ What to Order

Expert recommendations based on quality, value, and visitor feedback

Item Price
Veggie Omelette with Jalapeños
A hearty three-egg omelette loaded with fresh vegetables and a spicy jalapeño kick; comes with toast and hashbrowns.
 $9.25
Breakfast French Toast
Thick slices of golden-brown French toast, dusted with powdered sugar and served with syrup and butter.
 $7.50
Biscuits and Gravy
Classic homemade biscuits smothered in rich, peppery sausage gravy—a Midwest comfort staple.
 $8.00
Bacon Cheeseburger
Freshly grilled beef patty topped with crispy bacon and cheddar, served on a toasted bun with fries or chips.
 $10.50
Scrambled Eggs
Fluffy, perfectly scrambled eggs, served with your choice of toast and breakfast potatoes.
 $6.75
Pie Ala Mode
Homemade pie of the day, served warm with a scoop of classic vanilla ice cream.
 $5.25

Menu Highlights: Cafe On the Park’s menu is a masterclass in classic American breakfast and lunch done right. The Veggie Omelette with Jalapeños is a top pick for those craving flavor and heat, while the Biscuits and Gravy satisfy anyone seeking Midwest comfort food nostalgia. Breakfast French Toast is a sweet favorite—perfect for both kids and adults—and the Bacon Cheeseburger is a reliable lunch option with generous toppings and a side of crispy fries. Don’t overlook the Pie Ala Mode; visitors rave about the rotating flavors and the old-school, homemade touch.

Signature Dishes & Local Favorites: Based on visitor feedback and local insights, the biscuits and gravy and the pie are the dishes most often mentioned as “must-try.” The omelettes, especially with jalapeños, stand out for freshness and portion size. Regulars recommend asking about daily specials—these often feature seasonal ingredients or unique twists not on the standard menu.

Prices & Value: Most menu items fall in the $6–$11 range, making Cafe On the Park one of the best values in Lake Mills for breakfast or lunch. Portions are generous, and many reviewers note that you’ll leave full without breaking the bank.

Dietary Options & Allergen Info: While the menu emphasizes traditional fare (eggs, meat, bread, dairy), vegetarian options like the veggie omelette and customizable breakfast plates are available. Gluten-free choices are limited, so those with celiac or severe gluten intolerance should inquire with staff before ordering. Dairy and nut allergies can be accommodated if you notify your server—staff are known for their willingness to help, but cross-contamination is possible in a small kitchen. Vegan options are minimal.

Nutrition Details: As with most classic diners, expect generous use of butter, eggs, and cheese. If you’re watching calories or sodium, opt for simpler dishes like scrambled eggs and ask for modifications (e.g., dry toast, no cheese).

Takeout & Delivery: Takeout is available and popular, especially for early-morning breakfasts to-go. Delivery is not currently offered.

Reservations & Wait Times: Cafe On the Park operates on a first-come, first-served basis—no reservations. Weekends, especially mid-morning, can see a short wait, but turnover is quick. Arriving before 8am or after 1pm is your best bet for immediate seating.

Payment & Tipping: The café accepts cash and major credit cards. Standard tipping customs apply (15–20% for table service), and visitors report that staff are friendly and attentive, making gratuity well-earned.

✨ The Experience

🏡
Cozy, Small-Town Ambiance
Cafe On the Park exudes classic diner charm, with vintage touches, sunny windows, and a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere. Research shows regulars love the “everyone knows your name” vibe, making it a true community hub. The décor and building’s historic roots (dating back to the 1800s) add authentic character.
🤝
Friendly, Fast Service
Service is consistently described as attentive and personable—staff often greet regulars by name and go out of their way for newcomers. Orders are taken promptly and food arrives quickly, reflecting a well-oiled team that knows the breakfast and lunch rushes inside out.
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦
Family-Friendly, Lively Crowd
Expect a lively mix of families, retirees, and local workers, especially on weekends. Noise levels are comfortably busy—there’s a cheerful hum of conversation, but it rarely gets overwhelming. Early mornings tend to be quieter, making it great for solo diners or small groups seeking a peaceful meal.
🪑
Classic Diner Seating
Seating includes booths, tables, and a classic counter—perfect for everything from family breakfasts to solo coffee breaks. The layout is open and accessible, with enough space for wheelchairs and strollers. Groups of 4–6 fit comfortably, but larger parties may need to split up during peak times.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Does Cafe On the Park accommodate dietary restrictions?
While the menu is focused on classic American fare, vegetarian options are available and staff can often customize orders for allergies or dietary needs. Gluten-free and vegan choices are limited—always inform your server about any severe allergies, as cross-contact is possible in a small kitchen.
Is there typically a wait for a table on weekends?
Weekends, especially late mornings, can get busy with locals and visitors. Wait times are usually brief (10–20 minutes) and turnover is fast. For minimal wait, visit before 8am or after 1pm, or come on a weekday for a more relaxed experience.
Can I order takeout, and is delivery available?
Takeout orders are welcome—many locals grab breakfast to go, especially during the workweek. Delivery is not offered at this time. Call ahead during peak hours for the quickest service.

📖 About Cafe On the Park

Cafe On the Park is more than just a breakfast spot—it’s a living piece of Lake Mills history. Housed in a building dating back to the 1800s (originally a horse stable), the café has operated in its current form since the early 1940s, making it a staple for generations of locals. Over the decades, it has maintained its reputation for hearty, affordable meals and warm, welcoming service. The café’s central location on Main Street puts it at the heart of community life, serving everyone from families and retirees to early-morning workers and out-of-town visitors. Its continued popularity is a testament to its commitment to quality, consistency, and genuine small-town hospitality. Whether you’re starting your day with a classic breakfast or winding down with a slice of homemade pie, Cafe On the Park delivers the kind of comfort and connection that keeps people coming back year after year.